Two mothers went public
to air CPS corruption

 PAPA People Assisting Parents Association

© 2007-2012
Bookmark and Share
notice board blogger icon
New links
PAPA logo

Impacts on Children, Families and Society

  1. The Negative Effects of Foster Care on Removed Children

    (archived on June 3, 2010)


  2. Critical Injuries and Deaths of B.C. Children and Youth "In Care" of MCFD

    According to "Representative's Report - Critical Injuries and Deaths: Reviews and Investigations" published quarterly by the Representative of Children and Youth, the number of critical injuries and deaths of B.C. children and youth who were "in care" or receiving reviewable services are listed below:

    Report #


    Report Date


    Period Between

    Critical Injuries Reported and Selected for Review

    Deaths Reported and Selected for Review

    1 Nov. 7, 2007 June 1, 2007 and Sept. 30, 2007 69 (59) 26 (3)
    2 Feb 26, 2008 Oct. 1, 2007 and Jan. 31, 2008 46 (15) 31 (4)
    3 July 9, 2008 Feb. 1 and May 31, 2008 48 (10) 26 (2)
    4 Nov. 4, 2008 June 1 and Sept. 30, 2008 50 (24) 27 (2)
    5 March 18, 2009 Oct. 1, 2008 to Jan. 31, 2009 44 (13) 13 (5)
    6 July 9, 2009 Feb. 1, 2009 to May 31, 2009 49 (17) 30 (4)
    7 Nov. 12, 2009 June 1, 2009 – Sept. 30, 2009 49 (15) 34 (2)
    8 March 15, 2010 Oct. 1, 2009 – Jan. 31, 2010 43 (9) 25 (0)
    9 July 7, 2010 February 1, 2010 to May 31, 2010 35 (8) 27 (2)
    10 November 4, 2010 June 1, 2010 to September 20, 2010 34 (12) 32 (2)
    11 March 15, 2011 October 1, 2010 – January 31, 2011 41 (20) 35 (2)
    12 14 July 2011 1 February 2011 – 31 May 2011 123 (97) 23 (5)
    13 17 November 2011 1 June 2011 – 30 September 2011 142 (54) 28 (3)
    Total 773 (353) 357 (36)

               

    (n) where n denotes the number of cases of critical injuries and deaths while children were in care of MCFD (including Aboriginal children or youth).

    [The above table was last updated on 23 December 2011.]

  3. CPS accused parents of
    medical child abuse ...
    Children in the "care" of MCFD commit suicide, die of accident, are killed or abused (see MCFD's statistics). A web site called "Protected to Death by CPS" has been established in memory of children died when "in care" of "child protection" service [added on June 12, 2009].
  4. According to a 2008 study by Mary Ellen Turpel-Lafond (Representative for children and youth in B.C.),

    • 44% of adolescents receiving services from MCFD end up facing criminal charges;
    • 36% of kids in care are going to jail;
    • only 24% of foster children finish high school.

    (source document: Lori Culbert, Canwest News Service published: Thursday, June 26, 2008).

  5. According to the joint major study released by the Representative for Children and Youth and the Provincial Health Officer on February 23, 2009:

    [added on February 24, 2009]

  6. According to the Growing Up In B.C. report released by the Representative for Children and Youth and the Provincial Health Officer on October 18, 2009:

    • Children in care are nearly three times more likely to consider suicide – and nearly six times more likely to have attempted suicide at least once – than youth who have never been in care.
    • Aboriginal children and children in care are less likely to experience success in school.
    • Children in care are more likely to engage in risky behaviour, such as using tobacco, alcohol and drugs.
    • Children in care are more likely to have gone to bed hungry.
    • Youth in care consistently talked about the challenges they face in everyday life, such as creating and maintaining long-term relationships, having no-one to see them graduate, not having adult support or financial means to encourage them to do well in school or apply for post-secondary education.

    [added on October 20, 2010]

  7. According to "Legal delays could double number of cases tossed" (Vancouver Sun 29 July 2011), 65 criminal cases have been tossed in British Columbia Provincial Court from 1 January 2011 to 29 July 2011 because of significant delays in the legal system. If the trend continues, the number of cases stayed in 2011 because of delays could be more than double the 56 cases dropped in 2010.

    The Ministry often seeks child protection hearings that require many court days. This will guarantee that hearings will take place far in the future, hence lengthening the child holding period for the benefit of the "child protection" industry and allowing time to fabricate "evidence" to support the Ministry's legal actions. Many of these hearings are eventually canceled by the Ministry due to return of children to parents in some weak cases (to avoid their abuse of power being uncovered in hearings) or beating parents to agree to the Ministry's position. These hearings are often canceled shortly before hearing dates. This scheduling tactic deprives scarce and expensive court time to hear other more important cases. As a result, more and more criminal cases are judicially stayed due to a breach of charter right of failing to try within a reasonable time [Section 11 (b) of Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms]. Although criminal cases dropped are often of a minor nature, the function of the judiciary to provide efficient and timely adjudication is impaired. Society suffers because some criminals walk free and may re-commit due to a lack of deterrent.

    [added on 2 August 2011]

  8. The previous point also confirms the view of the American scholar Professor Stephen Baskerville written in the Insight Magazine (June 18, 2001) that it is to the interest of the judiciary to pack the courts with cases:

    "The one great principle of the law," wrote Dickens, "is to make business for itself." Like all courts, family courts complain of being overburdened. Yet it is clearly in their interest to be overburdened, since judicial powers and salaries, like any other, are determined by demand for their services. "Judges and staff ... should be given every consideration for salary and the other perks or other emoluments of their high office," Judge Page suggests, adding that divorce-court judges should aim to increase their volume of business. "As the court does a better job more persons will be attracted to it," he observes. He also writes, "The better the family-court system functions, the higher ... the volume of the persons served." A court "does a better job" by attracting more mothers (who file the overwhelming majority of divorces) with windfall divorce settlements.

    Publicity of criminal cases tossed will create public concern. This will pressure government to hire more judges and build more courthouses to ease the artificially created caseload. Taxpayer is a vulnerable and easy target.

    [added on 3 August 2011]



[This page was separated from the "Empirical Data & Stats" page on 20 October 2010, last revised on 3 August 2011.]